Reviewing the Rookie Classes: 2004
The last seven seasons have seen the advent of a youth movement in NASCAR at the Cup level. Young Guns have taken over in large numbers and many have quickly found success. Since 2000 a rookie has won a race in every season except 2004. Going back to 2002 the recent rookie classes have been pretty impressive. 12 of 19 drivers have won races, nine have made a Chase appearance and one has won two championships. Not bad for a wave of drivers that some fans complained were ruining the sport (Toyota and open wheel drivers have since acquired that “honor”). So which rookie class featured the best rookies? It’s a tough decision. I decided to look at the various classes from 2002-2006. I didn’t rate the 2007 class because drivers deserve at least three seasons for a fair assessment. The only reason I included the 2006 class was because it included so many drivers with immediate success it was an exceptional case. This week focuses on the 2003 class. Check out previous reviews: 2002, 2003.
The 2004 Class (Kasey Kahne, Brian Vickers, Scott Riggs, Scott Wimmer, Johnny Sauter, Brendan Gaughan, Carl Edwards)
Kasey Kahne took the Cup world by storm in 2004 when he finished 2nd in two of the first three races, narrowly losing to Matt Kenseth at Rockingham and Las Vegas. While he couldn’t find victory lane as a rookie, he did finish 2nd 5 times. His good looks also didn’t hurt for attracting fans and sponsors. He easily won rookie of the year and almost made the Chase, eventually settling for 13th place in the standings. He finished the season with 13 top 5’s, 14 top 10’s and 4 poles.
Amid raised expectations 2005 was a struggle. He won his first Cup race at Richmond, but had an overall disappointing sophomore season. The big breakthrough finally came in 2006 when he won 6 races, all at intermediate tracks, and made the Chase. While he still has some inconsistency issues, Kahne is one of the top drivers at intermediate tracks and can also excel at short tracks. He has proven his speedway prowess again this year with two more wins so far.
Kahne was the runaway surprise of the 2004 rookie class. That instant success was initially pegged for another driver. Brian Vickers won the 2003 Busch Championship and at the time was expected to easily adjust to the Cup level with Hendrick Motorsports. Of course people forgot that Vickers was only 20. While teammates Jimmie Johnson and Jeff Gordon were fighting for titles, Vickers struggled like almost any 20 year old would. Looking back it should have been expected, especially given the tough circumstances at the end of 2004. The Hendrick team was struck by tragedy which included the loss of Vickers’ close friend Ricky Hendrick. Despite his struggles he still managed 4 top tens and two poles as a rookie.
2005 and 2006 saw improvement and several times looked capable of winning. Vickers did finally win in the fall Talladega race, but at the expense of wrecking his teammate, Jimmie Johnson, and Dale Earnhardt Jr, which hardly cultivated fans for Vickers. After the 2006 season he sought a fresh start with the brand new Toyota Red Bull team. Like every Toyota team in 2007, Vickers struggled to make races and finished 38th in points. This year he has elevated his game and is again on the verge of winning races. Maybe it’s because he’s in his fifth Cup season, but it’s easy to forget that he is only 24. While it wasn’t a straight ascent to the top as expected Vickers is finally realizing his potential.
Brendan Gaughan scored what appeared to be a top ride for a rookie when Penske Racing South signed him to drive for the 2004 season. Coming off a six win Truck season in 2003, he appeared ready for the next level. Like most normal rookies, he struggled to finish races and only scored four top tens all season. He was let go after the season to make way for another rookie, Travis Kvapil. Gaughan returned to the Truck Series where he still drives for his family’s team. He made one substitute appearance for Haas-CNC in 2005, wrecked Kyle Petty, and has not resurfaced on the Cup level since. While Gaughan was far from brilliant in his rookie season, Kvapil did not fare any better in the same car the next year. Maybe he would have improved with more time, but it looks like Gaughan’s one chance at the Cup level is all he will get.
It took Scott Riggs a few years to gain traction at the Cup level he improved in each of his first three seasons. After a move from MB/2 Motorsports to Evernham in 2006 Riggs posted 1 top 5, 8 top 10’s and won two poles and finished 20th in the points. Unfortunately Riggs saw everything around him unravel in 2007 as the organization made some major engineering mistakes and Riggs fell outside the top 35. While Riggs is a steady driver and capable of piloting a fast car, he seems destined to be a career journeyman. 2009 will mark his fourth team in six Cup seasons.
Scott Wimmer nearly pulled off one of the biggest shocks of 2004 right off the bat. He gambled on pit strategy at the Daytona 500 and suddenly found himself in the lead with 29 laps to go. He eventually lost the lead but held on for an impressive 3rd place finish. Unfortunately it is Wimmer’s only top 5 to date at the Cup level. After two unremarkable years with Bill Davis Racing and one forgettable year with the struggling Morgan-McClure team Wimmer returned to the Nationwide Series where he runs a part time schedule and tests for RCR. He won the Nationwide race at Nashville earlier this year. His connection with RCR will likely continue to land him occasional Cup starts.
Based on his solid results in the lower ranks and the Busch Series, Johnny Sauter was given a chance on the Cup side with Richard Childress Racing. He began the season in the #30 AOL car and like every other rookie excluding Kahne, Sauter struggled. After failing to score a top ten in his first 13 races he was released in favor of veteran Dave Blaney. He has since landed rides with Phoenix Racing and Haas Racing with limited success. Sauter has three career top tens at the Cup level including a best of 5th.
Ironically, Sauter’s early exit eventually led to RCR hiring Jeff Burton to drive the car in midseason. Burton’s exit from Roush paved the way for a young driver to take NASCAR by surprise. Carl Edwards jumped into the #99 car at the August Michigan race and scored a top ten. While the rest of the season was not as smooth, he did have 5top tens in only 13 races.
Originally pegged to one day replace Mark Martin, Edwards had carved out his own identity with the #99 car. He won his first Cup race in style, passing Jimmie Johnson on the final turn at Atlanta. He then pulled off his signature backflip for the first time in a Cup race. He won four races and made the Chase field. With a late surge he nearly won the Chase but finished tied for second with teammate Greg Biffle.
Edwards struggled to repeat his charmed 2005 and went winless in 2006 and missed the Chase. He rebounded in 2007 with three wins and a spot in the Chase. He also has three wins through 19 races in 2008 and is in good shape to make his third Chase in four full seasons.
Verdict: The 2004 class had seven drivers which increases the odds that at least one driver will succeed, but three out of seven drivers are Cup winners and top 20 drivers. The rest makeup the underappreciated NASCAR workforce. The class gets a big boost from Edwards’ inclusion. Edwards and Kahne are bona fide stars at the Cup level, while Vickers is a very solid driver that is still improving. Scott Riggs and Johnny Sauter are both capable drivers that probably will remain Cup journeymen with the occasional highlights. Scott Wimmer has found success with RCR’s Nationwide team and will probably get another chance at the Cup level. Gaughan will likely remain a footnote for the rookie class.
